Starting a riot in Sidi Bouzid

Tunisia’s election is finally over and we have the first post-uprising victory of a Brotherhood calque.  But the events in Sidi Bouzid certainly marred the process. I turned up there mid-Friday afternoon when the  town courthouse and National Guard building were still burning furiously. Teenagers were talking around with burning plastic bags to spread the fires further. Documents were lying all over the road, with some desks and chairs. Some two dozen cars were burned out, while their tyres had been removed. The destruction inside the buildings was total. Shelves of archive inside the justice building were smouldering away, electricity wires dangled around dangerously, a few soldiers wandered in and out in an attempt, I suppose, to declare the state’s desire for the vandalism and looting to end. Townspeople came in to gawp at the ruin of the justice building and they appeared as bemused by the scene as the few journalists who had driven for hours along the unkempt country roads.

Talking to people to try and establish a picture of what happened did not clear matters up. The main point that everyone agreed on was that Sidi Bouzid felt insulted by the electoral commission scrubbing the votes of Hachmi Hamdi’s Popular Petition only and on one else’s. They also disliked the way journalists in the room whooped in delight when the commission made its announcement on Thursday night. Both points seemed to confirm to them the marginalisation and disdain they feel from the rest of the country, specifically the affluent elites of the coastal cities. Some had not voted for Hamdi’s party but felt anger just the same. But many people felt embarrassed by the vandalism, which after all just feeds the narrative that those who live in the Styx of the interior are rough and uncivilised. Some people said those who did it had come in vehicles from outside town and bore the accents of Sfax. There was a lot of anger over comments they believed Ennahda’s secretary-general (and likely prime minister) Hamdi Jbeli made on Hannibal TV describing them as ignorant countryfolk.

There is however no indication he made them at all. What did happen was Jbeli was asked on a radio station on Tuesday if Ennahda was prepared to bring Hamdi’s party into its coalition, to which he replied that Ennahda was only interested in joining with “those who fought against Ben Ali”. Hamdi himself spoke out against these comments in indignation on his London-based channel al-Mustaqilla on Tuesday night, addressing the people of Sidi Bouzid, where he is from, and Qairawan specifically. On Friday leaflets appeared among the crowds in Sidi Bouzid calling for a general  strike, and denouncing a “campaign of denigration led by the political elites and national media some of which described us as ignorant”. There was no signature.

It seems pretty clear there was manipulation behind the violence in Sidi Bouzid. If Hamdi wasn’t behind it, he at least allowed himself to be used to fan the flames. This was the defunct Ben Ali RCD party’s coda to the election, its only successful attempt at spoiling the show. The comments of people of Sidi Bouzid continually came back to one point: al-jihawiyya, or “regionalism”; disdain of the centre for those on the social, economic and political margins. I don’t think it quite rises to the level of the hogra that Algerians feel from the state, but it’s close. “Our demands are firstly no to regionalism and I say it again and again:  no to regionalism!” one man who gave his name as Lamine said. “Secondly,  we suffer from huge unemployment here, although we have a lot of people with higher education qualifications. To the political parties I say, we are proud of Hamdi. If you didn’t like his election campaign, you should have ejected him from the beginning. He  has his votes and he has his supporters.” Ennahda also has its supporters there: of the eight seats people voted for, Ennahda got two of them and had the highest votes of any party. 

The Islamists in the metropolitan centre want to reorientate Tunisia towards the Arab-Islamic world. They do not want to cut links with Europe and the Americans, or least that is one of the talking points they have been very careful to push over the past two weeks (though I think one should also note other things being said: on Hannibal Jbeli spoke out forcefully against French comments on being “vigilant” about “red lines” on democracy and human rights that Ennahda must not cross – “enough overlording and giving lessons” – and Ghanouchi himself talked on radio about French language pollution in Tunisian Arabic). For better or worse, they are saying they will stay open to Western investment (though I think they and their leftist coalition partners will be careful to protect certain sectors of the economy). But they will have to be careful about Tunisia’s “soft underbelly” – the interior where 3G networks don’t work, where resentment is strong and easily exploitable, and where there’s nothing to stop Ben Ali people motoring into town to start a riot.

Author:
Date: Saturday, 29. October 2011 18:44
Trackback: Trackback-URL Category: Commentary

Feed for the post RSS 2.0 Comment this post

3 comments

  1. 1

    The threat of Suez Canal closure, cutting of natural gas supplies to Israel, increased weapons flow to Gaza, and even of direct conflict with Israel, brings to mind the prophecy that before the Redemption “I will set Egyptians against Egyptians; everyone will fight against his brother, and everyone against his neighbor, city against city, kingdom against kingdom. The spirit of Egypt will fail in its midst (Yeshaya 19).

    “Egypt will become a waste, and Edom (Jordan) will become a desolate wilderness, because of the violence done to the sons of Judah, in whose land they have shed innocent blood” (Yoel 3).

    “I will make the land of Egypt utterly waste and desolate, from the tower of Syene (Aswan Dam?!) even unto the border of Ethiopia. And I will make the land of Egypt and her cities desolate for forty years; I will scatter the Egyptians and disperse them among the nations” (Yechezkel 29).

    “He will extend his power over many countries; Egypt will not escape. He shall have power over the treasures of gold and of silver, and over all the precious things of Egypt” (Daniel 11).

    “This will be the punishment of Egypt and of all the nations that refuse to go up to celebrate the Festival of Sukkos” (Zechariah 14).

    “The Anti-Moshiach Armilus will rule from Gaza” (Midrash Talpios).

    “He will fall in the face of all his brothers” (Breishis 25) – ‘at the End of Days when the Ishmaelites will fall by their own hands, then will Ben Dovid come’ (Ba’al HaTurim).

    “In 20 or 30 years the Egyptian regime will fall and be replaced with new leaders who will abrogate the peace treaty” (Lubavitcher Rebbe 1981).

    But ultimately there will be true peace in the Middle East: “In that day Israel will be the third, along with Egypt and Assyria, a blessing on the earth. The L-rd will bless them, saying, ‘Blessed be Egypt my people, Assyria my handiwork, and Israel my inheritance’” (Yeshaya 19)

  2. 2

    Finally there is a chance for the Arab nations to get their sovereignty and the people to start being alive. Thank you Bouazizi

  3. 3

    Ya may Allah bring many Tanaka on Muslim ummah Ameen

Submit comment